Members of Parliament that do what their party promised, even if it means going against what their constituents want, or Members of Parliament that do what their constituents want, even if it means going against what their party promised?
From the MyDemocracy.ca questionnaire, 2016.
The promise
On June 16, 2015, Justin Trudeau stood up to give the democratic-reform speech of his campaign. He promised to end first-past-the-post, the system in which the candidate with the most votes in a riding wins and every other vote elects no one. The point, he said, was to make every vote count.
We are committed to ensuring that 2015 will be the last federal election conducted under the first-past-the-post voting system.
Liberal platform, Real Change, page 27, 2015
The same page set the timetable. An all-party committee would study ranked ballots, proportional representation, mandatory voting and online voting. Within 18 months of forming government, the Liberals would introduce a law to change the system.
They won. On December 4, 2015, the Governor General read the promise into the Speech from the Throne, word for word, after a new opening: "To make sure that every vote counts." The new minister, Maryam Monsef, got it in her mandate letter. In May 2016 her department put it in writing that first-past-the-post "was designed to address a 19th century reality and is not suitable to meet the needs of 21st century Canadians." Canada was one of only three of the 34 OECD countries still using it.
It is better for several parties to have to govern together than for one party to make all the decisions in government, even if it takes longer for government to get things done.
From the MyDemocracy.ca questionnaire, 2016.
Thirty-nine point five
The election of October 19, 2015 showed the problem the promise was meant to fix. The Liberals won 39.5 percent of the vote and 54.4 percent of the seats. That was a majority government, with every decision in one party's hands, on fewer than four votes in ten.
| Party | Votes | Seats | Votes per seat |
|---|---|---|---|
| Liberal | 39.5% | 184 (54.4%) | 37,700 |
| Conservative | 31.9% | 99 (29.3%) | 56,700 |
| NDP | 19.7% | 44 (13.0%) | 78,800 |
| Bloc Québécois | 4.7% | 10 (3.0%) | 82,100 |
| Green | 3.4% | 1 (0.3%) | 602,933 |
A Green vote was worth one sixteenth of a Liberal vote. The minister said so herself in May 2016: "In a multi-party democracy like Canada, first past the post distorts the will of the electorate."
Then the government built its reform committee the same way. Its first plan gave the Liberals six of the ten voting seats, a majority of the committee from 39.5 percent of the vote. Nathan Cullen of the NDP called it what it was: "The Liberals have chosen to maintain their false majority on the committee, stacked the decks."
On June 2, 2016, the government backed down and accepted Cullen's plan: twelve members, seated in proportion to the vote, so no party held a majority. The House adopted it on June 7, 229 to 91. The one committee that ran on proportional rules was the one studying them.
Members of Parliament should always act in the interests of their constituents, even if it means going against their own party.
From the MyDemocracy.ca questionnaire, 2016.
The committee
The Special Committee on Electoral Reform did the work it was given. It sat through the summer and the fall of 2016 and toured the country, from Victoria to St. John's to Iqaluit.
The committee wrote down what it heard. Of the people who wanted change, the "overwhelming majority of testimony was in favour of proportional representation." Its report, Strengthening Democracy in Canada, was tabled on December 1, 2016. It asked for a referendum, with the current system on the ballot, against a proportional system scored by a standard measure of fairness, the Gallagher index, at 5 or less.
The five Liberal members dissented from their own committee's report. They called its recommendations "rushed" and "too radical to impose at this time."
The same afternoon, the minister answered for it in the House.
While it did not complete the hard work we had expected it to, this is consistent with what we heard from Canadians.
Maryam Monsef, Minister of Democratic Institutions, Question Period, December 1, 2016
She mocked the index too. Did Canadians want a referendum on "the square root of the sum of the squares of the difference between the percentage of the seats for each party and the percentage of the votes"? She apologized the next day. The same afternoon, she had announced what came next: "a digital initiative."
A ballot should be easy to understand, even if it means voters have fewer options to express their preferences.
From the MyDemocracy.ca questionnaire, 2016.
The survey
MyDemocracy.ca opened on December 5, 2016. A card went to almost 15 million homes. The Privy Council Office had hired Vox Pop Labs, the firm behind Vote Compass, to build it.
It asked how you felt about values: accountability, simple ballots, small parties, online voting. Then it sorted you into one of five "archetypes" built from a pre-study of 4,273 people: Guardians, Challengers, Pragmatists, Cooperators or Innovators. It never asked which voting system you wanted. Its own final report says so.
Associating users with an archetype emulates the viral model of online personality quizzes … Despite their popularity, online personality quizzes offered by Internet media companies command little if any credibility.
MyDemocracy.ca final report, Vox Pop Labs for the Privy Council Office, January 24, 2017
The opposition laughed it out of the room on day one. Conservative Scott Reid said it "feels like being on a dating website designed by Fidel Castro." Elizabeth May thought it was a dating survey that forgot to ask about piña coladas. Nathan Cullen called it "a pop-psych survey from this minister and there's no mention of electoral systems whatsoever."
| Vox Pop Labs contract, with tax | $369,058 |
|---|---|
| Postage for the cards | $1,673,921 |
| Printing the cards | $295,128 |
| Total | about $2.34 million |
The site promised your answers would stay anonymous. It also called Facebook the moment the page loaded. The Privacy Commissioner found the complaint well-founded: no privacy impact assessment, and no consent for sharing with Facebook.
The survey closed on January 15, 2017. About 383,074 people had finished it. The report was delivered on January 24. Its findings rested on the 243,057 answers that could be weighted, and its headline was that Canadians held values that pull in different directions: 70 percent wanted parties to share accountability, while 53 percent wanted it always clear which single party was accountable. Cullen had the last word that week: "When you insult Canadians with vague questions you get unclear answers, which may have cynically been what they wanted all along."
There should be parties in Parliament that represent the views of all Canadians, even if some are radical or extreme.
From the MyDemocracy.ca questionnaire, 2016.
The letter
Eight days after the report, on February 1, 2017, the new minister, Karina Gould, received her mandate letter from the Prime Minister. One paragraph ended the promise, and it used the survey to do it.
There has been tremendous work by the House of Commons Special Committee on Electoral Reform, outreach by Members of Parliament by all parties, and engagement of 360,000 individuals in Canada through mydemocracy.ca. A clear preference for a new electoral system, let alone a consensus, has not emerged. … Changing the electoral system will not be in your mandate.
Mandate letter to the Minister of Democratic Institutions, February 1, 2017
The same letter, a few paragraphs up, says: "It is important that we acknowledge mistakes when we make them."
In Question Period that afternoon, Trudeau said he had always preferred a ranked ballot, the NDP wanted proportional representation and the Conservatives wanted a referendum, so there was no consensus. "I am not going to do something that is wrong for Canadians just to tick off a box on an electoral platform." To Elizabeth May he added that "an augmentation of extremist voices in the House" was not in Canada's interest.
Over the next nine days he went further. In Iqaluit: "Proportional representation in any form would be bad for Canada." He asked the voter questioning him: “Do you think that Kellie Leitch should have her own party?” In Yellowknife, he said it plainly: "It is because I felt it was not in the best interests of our country and of our future that I turned my back on that promise."
The House voted on it twice. On February 14, 2017, a motion asking the government to apologize for breaking the promise failed, 130 to 173. On May 31, the motion to adopt the committee's report failed, 146 to 159. A petition asking the government to keep its word gathered 130,452 signatures. The answer came back with Gould's name on it: "Changing the electoral system is not in the Minister's mandate."
I am deeply afraid that this betrayal will strike much more deeply in the hearts of Canadians than Prime Minister Trudeau realizes, particularly among young people.
Elizabeth May, February 1, 2017
Having many small parties in Parliament representing many different views, or having a few big parties that try to appeal to a broad range of people?
From the MyDemocracy.ca questionnaire, 2016.
Three more elections
Canada has voted three more times under the system 2015 was supposed to retire. Each time, the seats and the votes told different stories.
| Election | Party | Votes | Seats |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 | Conservative | 34.3% | 121 |
| Liberal, governs | 33.1% | 157 | |
| 2021 | Conservative | 33.7% | 119 |
| Liberal, governs | 32.6% | 160 | |
| People's Party | 4.9% | 0 | |
| 2025 | Bloc Québécois | 1,236,349 votes | 22 |
| NDP | 1,234,673 votes | 7 |
In 2019 and again in 2021, the party with the most votes lost the election. In 2025 the Bloc and the NDP got almost the same number of votes, and the Bloc elected three times as many MPs. The NDP lost official party status.
The idea kept coming back, and kept being voted down. In May 2023 the Liberal Party's own convention asked the government for a National Citizens' Assembly on Electoral Reform. When the NDP put that motion, M-86, to the House on February 7, 2024, it failed 101 to 220. Thirty-nine Liberals voted for it. Trudeau voted against.
On January 6, 2025, announcing his resignation, he was asked for a regret.
If I have one regret, particularly as we approach this election … I do wish that we'd been able to change the way we elect our governments in this country so that people could choose a second choice or a third choice on the same ballot.
Justin Trudeau, January 6, 2025
His successor closed the subject in one sentence during the 2025 campaign. Mark Carney: "Candidly, it is not in the platform." In April 2026 Liberal delegates in Montreal voted down a resolution for a citizens' assembly on proportional representation, 235 to 315. That same month the Liberals reached a majority between elections, through five floor-crossers and three by-elections. The new elections law that took effect in June 2026 covers deepfakes and foreign interference. It does not touch the voting system.
Canada's electoral system is not perfect – no system is – but it has served our country well … for over 150 years. … Canadians have many reasons to be proud of their electoral system.
Government response to petition 451-01120, August 19, 2026
Voters should be able to express multiple preferences on the ballot, even if this means that it takes longer to count the ballots and announce the election result.
From the MyDemocracy.ca questionnaire, 2016.
The provinces tried
- British Columbia, 2005A citizens' assembly recommended a new system. 57.69 percent voted yes, and yes carried 77 of 79 ridings. The rule required 60 percent. It failed. Later votes in 2009 and 2018 went the other way.
- Ontario, 2007A citizens' assembly recommended mixed-member proportional. It got 36.82 percent, short of a 60 percent threshold.
- Prince Edward Island, 2016 and 2019In a 2016 plebiscite, mixed-member proportional won with 52.4 percent on the fourth count. The premier called the result "doubtful" as a clear expression of the will of Islanders. In the binding 2019 referendum it got 48.26 percent and carried 14 districts. The law required 17.
- Quebec, 2018 to 2021François Legault's CAQ signed a cross-party pledge for proportional voting in 2018 and tabled a bill in 2019. In April 2021 the minister said a referendum was "no longer on the table," and the bill died. In 2022 the CAQ won 72 percent of the seats with 41 percent of the vote.
- New Brunswick, 2005A commission recommended mixed-member proportional, and the government promised a referendum for May 2008. A new government took office in 2006. The vote was never held.
The pattern holds from coast to coast. The people who win under the current rules decide whether to change them.
It should always be clear which party is accountable for decisions made by government, even if this means that decisions are only made by one party.
From the MyDemocracy.ca questionnaire, 2016.
Your result
- Questions answered
- What your answers changed
- Nothing
- Next federal election
- October 15, 2029, under first-past-the-post
Every archetype got the same result. That was true in 2016 too, it just took eight weeks to show.
The site is still there. Go to mydemocracy.ca today and you reach the government's survey app, frozen on May 2, 2017, behind a security certificate that expired on September 4, 2022. Someone renewed the domain again last month. It says:
The MyDemocracy.ca initiative has now concluded. Thank you very much to everyone who participated. … Thank you again for having your say with MyDemocracy.ca.
www.mydemocracy.ca, unchanged since May 2, 2017
The promise was to make every vote count. Under first-past-the-post, a vote for anyone but the winner in your riding still elects nobody. You were asked for your say, and you gave it. The decision about whether your vote counts stayed with the people the old system elected.
Have your say. Again.
A National Citizens' Assembly on Electoral Reform is the idea the Liberal Party's own members backed in 2023 and the House voted down in 2024. Ordinary people, chosen at random, would study the options and recommend one. Ask your MP where they stand.
Ten cards you can post
Each card carries one line from this page. Pick one to post it, copy it or download it. Every post links back here.
Sources
- Liberal Party of Canada, Real Change: A New Plan for a Strong Middle Class (2015), page 27
- CBC: Justin Trudeau vows to end 1st-past-the-post voting in platform speech, June 16, 2015
- Speech from the Throne, Making Real Change Happen, December 4, 2015
- Mandate letter to the Minister of Democratic Institutions, November 2015 (archived)
- Democratic Institutions: Motion to Propose All-Party Parliamentary Committee on Electoral Reform, May 2016
- House of Commons debates, February 1, 2017 (Hansard, sitting 131)
- Elections Canada, 42nd general election, official voting results: votes by party
- Elections Canada, 42nd general election: seats by party
- CBC: Liberals propose electoral reform committee with Liberal majority, May 11, 2016
- CBC: Liberals accept NDP proposal for electoral reform committee, June 2, 2016
- Journals of the House of Commons, June 7, 2016: the committee created
- Special Committee on Electoral Reform, Report 3, Strengthening Democracy in Canada, December 1, 2016
- House of Commons debates, December 1, 2016 (Hansard, sitting 119)
- House of Commons debates, December 2, 2016: the minister's apology
- Democratic Institutions: MyDemocracy.ca launch, December 5, 2016
- Vox Pop Labs for the Privy Council Office, MyDemocracy.ca final report, January 24, 2017
- Answer to Order Paper question 744 on the cost of MyDemocracy.ca, January 30, 2017
- CBC: “A dating website designed by Fidel Castro”: opposition blasts Liberal electoral reform survey, December 6, 2016
- Office of the Privacy Commissioner: investigation of the MyDemocracy.ca website, 2017
- CBC: Liberal survey on voting reform delivers conflicting messages, January 25, 2017
- Mandate letter to the Minister of Democratic Institutions, February 1, 2017
- CBC: Trudeau abandons electoral reform, February 1, 2017
- CBC: Trudeau in Iqaluit on electoral reform and Kellie Leitch, February 9, 2017
- Canadian Press: Northerners press Trudeau on electoral reform, February 10, 2017
- Global News: Trudeau in Yellowknife, February 10, 2017
- CBC, Éric Grenier: how the 2015 election would have looked under other systems, November 26, 2015
- House of Commons vote 194: motion asking the government to apologize, February 14, 2017
- House of Commons vote 290: concurrence in the committee's report, May 31, 2017
- Petition e-616 and the government response
- Elections Canada, 43rd general election (2019), official results
- Elections Canada, 44th general election (2021), official results
- Elections Canada, 45th general election (2025), official results
- Liberal Party of Canada, 2023 policy resolutions: resolution 439
- House of Commons vote 634: M-86, citizens' assembly on electoral reform, February 7, 2024
- CBC: Trudeau says abandoning electoral reform is his biggest regret, January 9, 2025
- National Post: Carney says he is open to electoral reform, April 25, 2025
- Hill Times: Liberal delegates vote against electoral reform, April 11, 2026
- CP24: Carney's Liberals win a majority after by-elections, April 14, 2026
- LEGISinfo: Bill C-25, Strong and Free Elections Act
- Petition 451-01120 and the government response, August 19, 2026
- Legislative Assembly of British Columbia: the 2005, 2009 and 2018 electoral referenda
- 2007 Ontario electoral reform referendum (results from Elections Ontario)
- CBC: P.E.I. plebiscite result and the premier's response, November 8, 2016
- Elections PEI: 2019 referendum results
- CBC: P.E.I. referendum district count corrected, 2019
- National Assembly of Quebec: Bill 39, An Act to establish a new electoral system
- CBC: Quebec drops its electoral reform referendum, April 28, 2021
- New Brunswick Commission on Legislative Democracy, final report, 2005
- The MyDemocracy.ca survey as it ran, January 2017 (Wayback Machine)
- The MyDemocracy.ca “now concluded” page, September 2026 (Wayback Machine)